Category: Comics

Expanded Universe Round-Up #9

7/4/2023

The Followers (JA Special Edition #2)

Though not an amazing book, I much prefer this as an ending to the Jedi Apprentice series than The Threat Within. The first half is strong and benefits from the familiar rhythm of Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon working together as a team, but the second half is weaker and it feels as though Watson doesn't have the same grasp of Anakin's character that she does with the other Jedi.

But I was intrigued by the mystery and I didn't even mind that there were loose plot threads left at the end (because I know that one such thread is probably named Sidious lol). An okay finale to a series I love very much, even after two decades and that troublesome adulthood thing.

Legacy of the Jedi/Secrets of the Jedi

I consider both books presented here as part of the Jedi Apprentice series and I'm always happy to continue that journey, just that little bit longer. Watson manages to keep consistent storylines going through the eras she jumps into, each part showing us something about a different character. However, while the juvenile writing style works for the characters when they're younger, it's really jarring once the characters grow older. It just...feels off. Especially in the interactions between Anakin and Padmé.

But I would never skip these two books in my reread of my admittedly vast Legacy canon collection. For Siri Tachi fans, this is essential reading. I think it's obvious that I'm one of them!

The bonus story at the end is a good read, but it's nothing special.

Rise of the Sith (Dark Horse Omnibus)

Reading these comics has reminded me just how crowded the storytelling timeline around The Phantom Menace was in that era. Not all of the stories contained in this omnibus are good, but most of them are entertaining - and it was fun watching Darth Maul ferociously cut Black Sun down to size. The Ki-Adi-Mundi stories... are awful. It felt like the writer had a story they'd always wanted to tell and forced it to fit (if somewhat clumsily) into the Star Wars universe.

0 Comments

Expanded Universe Round-up #5

7/4/2023

0 Comments

The Dark Side (Jedi Vol 1)

A prequel to the Jedi Apprentice series that ended 10 years before this TPB hit shelves. The timing was strange, perhaps to entice readers who had since grown up. I was one of those and like any JA fan I was excited to finally see the fall of Xanatos. That excitement was short-lived. The story is a mess and the art is even messier... and it's clear the writer failed to understand why Xanatos was so intriguing as a villain.

How odd that a comic series aimed at adults lacks the maturity and character development of the YA books it drew inspiration from. This was obviously intended to continue with some sort of "Qui-Gon on a quest" arc, but I'm grateful to Disney for stopping it in its tracks.

Jedi Apprentice (1999-2002)

Back in 1999, I would venture into the "Teen" section at Borders (few stores had such a clear distinction between kids books and older books - YA as a label did exist, but didn't seem to be widely used) and imagine my delight when I discovered the Jedi Apprentice series. Thanks to these books, I feel like I grew up with Obi-Wan. I will always love them. And I will always remember how shocking it was back then, to discover that Obi-Wan's future as a Jedi was in jeopardy

The Rising Force (Jedi Apprentice #1)

This was the second JA book I ever read, having got my hands on book #2 first. Someone gave me another copy for my birthday and Mum, having kept the receipt, duly went and exchanged it for me. I remember the anxious wait in the car. And then she returned - with book #1! It was worth the wait. I enjoyed re-reading it today, all these years later, because though Wolverton didn't write the whole series, he did a damn good job of introducing it to us all.

Even now, I am impressed at how perfectly paced this book is, and how well the characters and their motivations are introduced, despite its length. That ending in the afterword is simply brilliant. Sure, I would have preferred it to be longer...but the days of meatier YA tales were still to come.

This remains one of my favourite books.

(PS: Yes, I did use my ancient cardboard JA bookmark while reading it...)

0 Comments

Expanded Universe Round-Up #4

19/2/2023

0 Comments

Spiral (Lost Tribe of the Sith)

Ah. The Lost Tribe of the Sith. My guilty pleasure. I'm glad there was one last piece of their history left to read - and of course I enjoyed it. Sure, we've had secret starships and secret inhabitants on the planet in other stories already... but this was undeniably fun (if a bit bonkers). Hilts was a fave of mine in the Lost Tribe print collection so I was pleased to see him. Too bad there's no more. I'd have happily read more of these.

Aflame (Knight Errant Vol 1)

Kerra Holt is given the correct medium this time (the novel did her and her storyline no favours) and she is able to truly shine in the comics. It's by no means a blinding shine, more of a dull gleam, but it's there. Kerra does get on my nerves a bit... I am hoping that some character development occurs. Alas, there aren't many TPBs in the series, so I suspect not.

Deluge (Knight Errant Vol 2)

I wish I could say this was an improvement, but at least it wasn't a step backwards. I'm rather bemused that John Jackson Miller, who is responsible for my favourite Star Wars comics (KOTOR), managed to create this lacklustre series. I do think it was a good decision to show Kerra's homeworld. The interactions she had there helped to add...at least one dimension to her character lol

Escape (Knight Errant Vol 3)

I suspected that Kerra Holt would enjoy no character development in this series and I was right. This is a disappointing volume in general and extremely disappointing as a conclusion (given the timing, it's obvious that the sale to Disney is the reason the series ended - a mercy killing, really). I felt underwhelmed by a storyline that should have done Big Things for Kerra...but didn't. We are left with the same old ending. More people to save. On repeat. Ad nauseum.

Jedi vs. Sith

I vaguely recall reading this a long time ago... back then it was considered a key piece of Legends canon. It isn't worthy of its prior status. Cartoonish in both art style and storyline, it impressed me when I was a younger, but now I see that it's somewhat nonsensical and there is no solid connection to the galaxy at large. It just seems strange that all this action would be limited to one world. But I still enjoyed this TPB, flaws and all. Perhaps nostalgia is to blame!

0 Comments

Expanded Universe Round-Up #3

17/1/2023

0 Comments

Blood of the Empire (The Old Republic Vol 1)

I'll start with the usual "I haven't played any of the games" disclaimer. I found this to be a pretty decent if unremarkable tale that offered no real surprises, because it features Sith being...well, Sith. Teneb Kel is the standard copy-and-paste Sith. I was happy to see him succeed, however.

Threat of Peace (The Old Republic Vol 2)

What a mess! Disjointed to the point of being confusing... never lingering long enough in one place for me to connect to any of the characters (or give a damn about them)... I really wish I could claw back the time I lost while reading this TPB and it wasn't even that long!

Also, why the heck did the artist literally draw the Sydney Harbour Bridge into the background of one panel? It was horribly jarring.

The Lost Suns (The Old Republic Vol 3)

This is the first TPB of the series that actually gave me a real sense of the setting used in the video games - and the first competently executed story (the previous TPBs...yikes). I became quite fond of Theron Shan and his companions while reading these pages. I'm not sad that I finished a lacklustre series, but at least it ended on a strong note.

0 Comments

Book Reviews

Expanded Universe Round-Up #9

Expanded Universe Round-up #5

Expanded Universe Round-Up #4

Expanded Universe Round-Up #3

About

Archives

Categories